Skip main navigation
Balance Rewards

Checkout

You've Selected
Clear all selections

Refine Your Results

Product Category

Makeup

Product Type

Unchecked Box Eye Lashes (80)
Unchecked Box Eye Liner (27)
Unchecked Box Eyebrows (38)
Unchecked Box Liners - Liquid & Cream (43)
Unchecked Box Liners - Pencil (72)
Unchecked Box Mascara (133)
Unchecked Box Shadow Duos (21)
Unchecked Box Shadow Palettes (18)
Unchecked Box Shadow Quads (31)
Checked Box Shadow Singles
Unchecked Box Washable (28)

View More

Brand

Unchecked Box CoverGirl Eye Enhancers 1 Kit (1)
Unchecked Box CoverGirl Intense ShadowBlast (6)
Unchecked Box L'Oreal Infallible (1)
Unchecked Box L'Oreal Studio Secrets Professional (1)
Unchecked Box Maybelline ExpertWear Single (16)
Unchecked Box Maybelline EyeStudio (10)
Unchecked Box Milani (3)
Unchecked Box Milani Metallic Baked (3)
Unchecked Box Milani Runway Eyes Wet/Dry (4)
Unchecked Box Wet n Wild Color Icon Collection (2)

View More

Color

Unchecked Box After Midnight
(1)
Unchecked Box Amethyst
(1)
Unchecked Box Antique Jade
(1)
Unchecked Box Aubergine
(1)
Unchecked Box Beach Sand
(1)
Unchecked Box Bedazzled Biscotti
(1)
Unchecked Box Beige
(1)
Unchecked Box Blue
(1)
Unchecked Box Blue Blazes
(1)
Unchecked Box Brown
(1)
Unchecked Box Copper Craze
(1)
Unchecked Box Drench in Gold
(1)
Unchecked Box Fierce & Tangy
(1)
Unchecked Box Fusion
(1)
Unchecked Box Golden Halo
(1)
Unchecked Box Green
(1)
Unchecked Box I Heart You
(1)
Unchecked Box Intermix
(1)
Unchecked Box Linen
(1)
Unchecked Box Made for Mocha
(1)
Unchecked Box Melange
(1)
Unchecked Box Night Sky
(1)
Unchecked Box Nutmeg
(1)
Unchecked Box Nutty
(1)
Unchecked Box Pink
(1)
Unchecked Box Pink Petal
(1)
Unchecked Box Platinum
(1)
Unchecked Box Rich Java
(1)
Unchecked Box Royalty
(1)
Unchecked Box Satin Tutu
(1)
Unchecked Box Seashell
(1)
Unchecked Box Silken Taupe
(1)
Unchecked Box Silver Lining
(1)
Unchecked Box Tastefully Taupe
(1)
Unchecked Box Turquoise Glass
(1)
Unchecked Box Vanilla
(1)

Special Values

Unchecked Box Loyalty points eligible
(10)
Unchecked Box Sale, BOGO & Rebates
(32)
Unchecked Box Web Exclusive
(4)

Eye Shadow Singles

48  Items
CoverGirl Intense ShadowBlast Eye Shadow Brown Bling 815
CoverGirl Intense ShadowBlast Eye Shadow Brown Bling 815

0.27 oz.

$9.49

$7.99

Average, Ordinary (75 reviews)
Find at a store
Milani Metallic Baked Marbleized Eye Shadow Drench in Gold
Milani Metallic Baked Marbleized Eye Shadow Drench in Gold

0.05 z

$6.99

Find at a store
CoverGirl Intense ShadowBlast Eye Shadow Extreme Green 820
CoverGirl Intense ShadowBlast Eye Shadow Extreme Green 820

0.27 oz.

$9.49

$7.99

Average, Ordinary (75 reviews)
Find at a store
Milani Runway Eyes Wet/Dry Runway Eyes Eye Shadow Golden Touch
Milani Runway Eyes Wet/ Dry Runway Eyes Eye Shadow Golden Touch

0.07 oz.

$7.99

Find at a store
Milani Metallic Baked Eyeshadow Rich Java 607
Milani Metallic Baked Eyeshadow Rich Java 607

0.05 z

$6.99

Find at a store
Maybelline ExpertWear Single Stylish Smokes Eye Shadow Nutmeg Matte Finish 195
Maybelline ExpertWear Single Stylish Smokes Eye Shadow Nutmeg Matte...

0.09 oz.

Priced per store

In store only
Find at a store
Maybelline ExpertWear Single Stylish Smokes Eye Shadow Silken Taupe High Pearl Finish 180
Maybelline ExpertWear Single Stylish Smokes Eye Shadow Silken Taupe...

0.09 oz.

$4.29

That's Good Stuff (11 reviews)
Out of Stock Out of stock
Find at a store
Milani Runway Eyes Wet/Dry Eyeshadow
Milani Runway Eyes Wet/ Dry Eyeshadow

0.07 oz.

$7.99

Choose Options
48  Items

Price may vary by store location and may not match online pricing.